Skip to content

Personal Injury Challenges Government Immunity Law

government immunity, injured by contractor, injured by government employee

Government Immunity in Wisconsin

The government immunity law in Wisconsin is directly related to the long existing U.S. existing law of sovereign immunity. By design, its intention is to protect government employees from lawsuits. For many years however, courts have struggled with defining where to draw the line between protections and liabilities. The question is, ‘should the law protect every action of a government employee?” At what point do the government employees negligent or careless actions become a responsibility that they need to be liable for?

Decisions by state and federal courts over recent years reiterate the practical limits of government immunity laws. As a result, the views of government immunity laws continue to evolve as they are challenged. Instead of “immunity first and liability second,” the shift is becoming more like “liability first, and immunity” as a limited exception under the language of the law.

Exempt from Liability

Exempting someone from being liable for their actions or inactions that may have caused injury to another person, merely because they are a public official or work in one way or another for the government; it just doesn’t make much sense. This is why, as a general rule, government entities may still be subject to the same liabilities as private parties. Trying these cases may be complicated. However, if the action or inaction of a government employee resulted in injury to another person, there are circumstances whereby the government immunity law can, should, and will be challenged.

Holding Government Entities & Employees Accountable

Government immunity makes it difficult to hold a government contractor/employee responsible. However, during their course of their employment, they are no likely than anyone else to have accidents. For example:  If a public-school janitor left soapy water on the stairs of the school and your child fell on those stairs, the school could argue that they are not responsible for your child’s injuries because the law affords them immunity under this law.

Our firm brought a claim against a local city transit wherein they claimed governmental immunity. The bus company claimed immunity for their failure to properly secure a disabled person who sustained an injury.  A lawsuit was filed, and the bus company brought a motion to enforce the immunity. The court found in favor of the injured disabled client. Sometimes government entities appeal these decisions, as did the bus company. In the end, the case was later affirmed at the appellate level.

Courts are more often holding government employees liable for their actions as well; they can’t always rely on immunity. If all of the rules are not followed, any negligence that causes injury to another person could result in a liability or worse yet…a wrongful death case.

If you’ve been injured and need to talk to a personal injury attorney, contact Action Law Offices today.  We handle all types of personal injury cases. Your first consultation is free.

Leave a Comment


Before Contacting a Personal Injury Lawyer, You Should Know:

The insurance adjustor is on the insurance company’s side, not yours.

Some are aggressive and try to scare people into not making a claim or into accepting very little compensation. Other adjustors seem kind and helpful — and then use your own words to deny your claim. The bottom line: the less the insurance company has to pay out, the more incentive the adjustor has.

We will investigate to establish liability and damages.

Our law firm has extensive resources to investigate an accident and assess who was at fault, regardless of the accident type. We work with a range of investigators and experts whose expertise provides crucial information for our determination of a fair settlement value.

Our attorneys can explain your coverage and your rights.

If you were hit by an uninsured or underinsured driver, your insurance company may fail to tell you about your rights under your own policy. We can also help you understand your medical coverage under your health insurance policy.